Over the years, I’ve worked on hundreds of residential painting projects, and one thing has become very clear: homeowners often make avoidable mistakes when hiring a painting contractor. A paint job may seem straightforward, but choosing the right contractor is one of the most important steps to ensuring quality, efficiency, and a stress-free experience. I’ve seen these mistakes time and again, so I wanted to share the top five so you can avoid them.
1. Choosing Based on Price Alone
The first mistake I see many homeowners make is hiring solely based on the lowest bid. While it can be tempting to go with the cheapest option, a low price often comes with hidden costs. Contractors who offer very low estimates may cut corners, use lower-quality materials, or rush through the work to make up for lost time.
Quality painting requires preparation, proper tools, and skilled labor. If a contractor cannot provide these, the end result may look good at first but fail prematurely. Investing in a reputable painter like J Michael’s Painting may cost a little more upfront, but it ensures the job is done right the first time and saves money and headaches down the road.
2. Not Checking References or Past Work
Another common mistake is failing to check references or look at past projects. Every contractor should have a portfolio of completed work and clients who can speak to their experience. This is especially important because pictures and testimonials provide insight into both quality and professionalism.
When I meet a new client, I encourage them to ask for examples of similar projects we’ve completed. Seeing consistent results and hearing from satisfied homeowners helps build trust. It also sets realistic expectations for the outcome, including color, finish, and timing. A painting job is an investment, so it’s worth taking the time to research and confirm a contractor’s track record.
3. Skipping the Written Contract
Some homeowners make the mistake of relying on verbal agreements. While it may feel easier to trust a contractor, this approach can lead to misunderstandings about the scope of work, pricing, or project timeline.
A detailed written contract protects both the homeowner and the contractor. It should include the work to be done, the type of paint and materials, the estimated start and completion dates, and payment terms. At J Michael’s Painting, we always provide clear, written agreements to ensure everyone is on the same page. This eliminates confusion and keeps the project running smoothly from start to finish.
4. Underestimating the Importance of Preparation
Many homeowners focus solely on the finished look and overlook the work that goes into preparation. Skipping prep work is a mistake because it affects the longevity and appearance of the paint job. Proper preparation includes cleaning surfaces, sanding, filling holes, and taping edges.
I often tell clients, “You cannot hide poor preparation under a coat of paint.” Even the best paint will peel, crack, or show imperfections if the surfaces are not ready. A professional contractor invests the time and effort upfront to ensure the finish is smooth, even, and durable. Taking shortcuts in preparation may save time in the moment, but it often leads to more work and expenses in the future.
5. Failing to Communicate Clearly
Communication is another area where homeowners sometimes struggle. Not discussing expectations clearly can lead to misunderstandings about color choices, project timelines, or the number of coats required.
From the first consultation, I make it a priority to listen to my clients, explain the process, and keep them updated throughout the project. Homeowners should feel comfortable asking questions and sharing concerns at any stage. A contractor who communicates openly helps reduce stress and ensures the finished result matches the homeowner’s vision.
Bonus Tip: Trust Your Instincts
While these five mistakes are common, there is also something more subtle to keep in mind: trust your instincts. If a contractor seems disorganized, unprofessional, or evasive, it’s worth considering other options. Your gut can often alert you to red flags that aren’t obvious on paper.
Hiring a painting contractor is more than just hiring someone to brush walls. It’s about entrusting your home to professionals who respect your property, your time, and your expectations. Taking the time to research, communicate, and plan can make all the difference.
The Takeaway
Hiring a painting contractor doesn’t have to be stressful. Avoiding these common mistakes—choosing solely based on price, skipping references, not having a written contract, underestimating preparation, and failing to communicate—will help homeowners get the results they want.
At J Michael’s Painting, we focus on quality, attention to detail, and clear communication to ensure every project exceeds expectations. By taking the time to hire the right contractor and understanding what goes into a professional paint job, homeowners can enjoy a beautiful, long-lasting finish without the worry and frustration that comes from common mistakes.